Reminders of Him

Kenna Rowan pleads guilty to vehicular manslaughter for a car accident that resulted in the death of her boyfriend, Scotty Landry. Six years later, Kenna is released from prison on parole and moves back to her hometown in hopes of meeting her five-year-old daughter Diem, whom she gave birth to during her sentence and has been raised by Scotty's parents, Grace and Patrick.

Kenna moves into a low-income housing complex, where she adopts a kitten at her landlady's insistence. She also befriends Lady Diana, her younger neighbor with Down Syndrome whose father is incarcerated. After a fruitless day of job-searching, Kenna wanders into her and Scotty's favorite bookstore, which has been converted into a bar. She and the owner hit it off, but she declines his invitation to go on a date. She hastily leaves after realizing that he is Ledger Ward, Scotty's lifelong best friend who was in the NFL during their relationship. Ledger still lives on the same street as Grace and Patrick and acts as a surrogate uncle to Diem. Grace, meanwhile, dodges Diem's questions about her mother's absence.

With the help of Anna, a sympathetic grocery store worker, Kenna finally finds a job as a cashier. She stops by the Landry house, but Ledger, who is then leaving, realizes that she is Diem's mother. He, Grace, and Patrick still blame Kenna for Scotty's death and bar her from seeing her daughter.

While Grace and Diem are out shopping, they nearly wander into Kenna's store, but Ledger intercepts them and prevents Diem from seeing Kenna.

After receiving some advice from his friend and co-worker Roman, Ledger visits Kenna and they share a kiss, though Kenna pushes Ledger away, out of fear that they will complicate things further.

After a romantic date, Ledger insists on knowing how the evening of Scotty's death unfolded. Kenna then reads to him from her diary; the accident was caused because both she and Scotty were high, and Kenna was able to free herself from the car. The blood supply to Scotty's arm had stopped, so Kenna assumed he was dead. Desperate, she sought help, but no one came to her aid. She was eventually arrested, unconscious, by the police. Overwhelmed with guilt over his death and the fact that she hadn't realized Scotty was still alive, Kenna pleaded guilty. Only afterward did she learn that she was pregnant. Kenna also tearfully reveals that she never got the chance to hold Diem after giving birth, because the latter was born prematurely.

On Mother's Day, Diem expresses a desire to give flowers to her mother, so Ledger delivers a bouquet to Kenna. They go on another date but are discovered by Patrick who angrily punches Ledger for what he sees as betrayal. Ledger goes to Kenna's apartment but discovers she is packing with the intention of leaving. Unable to make her stay, he steals her diary and delivers it to Grace and Patrick, asking them to read the pages on Scotty's death.

After reading the pages, Grace, with a change of heart, visits Kenna to return the diary and tells her that Scotty would have wanted her to meet his daughter. Ledger sees Kenna arriving at Grace and Patrick's. They inform him that she is coming for dinner and invite Ledger to join. A nervous Kenna asks Ledger to come with her to meet Diem. Kenna originally only introduces herself as Ledger's friend but later, while playing, tells Diem that she is her mother. The reconciled family enjoy dinner and Diem falls asleep on Kenna.

Later, Ledger drives Kenna and Diem to the spot where the car crash occurred and they reinstate Scotty's roadside memorial. Kenna had stolen it on her way into town because Scotty didn't like memorials. She tells Diem it will make Grace happy.